What is the Difference Between 18 Electron Rule and EAN Rule?
🆚 Go to Comparative Table 🆚Both the 18-electron rule and the Effective Atomic Number (EAN) rule indicate that a stable compound should have a noble gas electron configuration. However, there are some differences between the two rules:
- Focus: The 18-electron rule specifically considers the valence electrons of the metal atom, while the EAN rule focuses on the total electron content of the metal atom.
- Application: The 18-electron rule is mainly applied to organometallic complexes, while the EAN rule can be applied more broadly to transition metals.
- Electron counting: The 18-electron rule simplifies the EAN rule by considering only the valence electrons of the transition metals, which can hold a total of 18 electrons.
In summary, both rules aim to describe the stability of compounds based on a noble gas electron configuration. The 18-electron rule is a simplification of the EAN rule, focusing on the valence electrons of the metal atom and is mainly applied to organometallic complexes. The EAN rule, on the other hand, considers the total electron content of the metal atom and can be applied more broadly to transition metals.
Comparative Table: 18 Electron Rule vs EAN Rule
The 18-electron rule and the EAN (Effective Atomic Number) rule are both concepts related to the stability of transition metal complexes. Here is a table comparing the differences between the two rules:
Feature | 18-Electron Rule | EAN Rule |
---|---|---|
Focus | Valence electrons of the metal atom | Total electron content of the metal atom |
Application | Mainly applicable to organometallic compounds | Applicable to a broader range of transition metal complexes |
Noble Gas Configuration | Requires 18 electrons to fill the valence shell | Requires electron configuration of the noble gas for the entire system |
Stability | Stable compounds have 18 valence electrons | Stable compounds have a noble gas configuration for the whole system |
Reactivity | Coordinatively unsaturated complexes tend to undergo associative reactions | Coordinatively unsaturated complexes tend to undergo oxidative addition or reductive elimination reactions |
Both rules indicate that obtaining a noble gas electron configuration makes a metal atom stable. The 18-electron rule focuses on the valence electrons of the metal atom, while the EAN rule considers the whole electron content of the metal atom. The 18-electron rule is mainly discussed under organometallic compounds, whereas the EAN rule is applicable to a broader range of transition metal complexes.
- Ion Electron Method vs Oxidation Number Method
- ISBN 10 vs ISBN 13
- Electron Affinity vs Electron Gain Enthalpy
- Photon vs Electron
- Proton vs Electron
- Ions vs Electrons
- Noble Gas Configuration vs Electron Configuration
- Visa vs Visa Electron
- C8 vs C18 Column
- EIN vs TIN
- Ionization Energy vs Electron Affinity
- Electronegativity vs Electron Affinity
- Free Electron Model vs Nearly Free Electron Model
- Federal Tax ID vs EIN
- Electron vs Beta Particle
- Electron vs Neutron Diffraction
- Barcode vs QR Code
- Electronic vs Ionic Conduction
- Valency vs Valence Electrons