What is the Difference Between Calcium Acetate and Calcium Carbonate?
🆚 Go to Comparative Table 🆚Calcium acetate and calcium carbonate are two widely used phosphate-binding agents that help control serum phosphorus levels in patients with kidney disease, particularly those undergoing hemodialysis. Although both agents have similar efficacy, there are some differences between them:
- Elemental Calcium Content: Calcium acetate contains less elemental calcium (325 mg) compared to calcium carbonate (500 mg).
- Hypercalcemia: Calcium acetate has been shown to result in less frequency of hypercalcemia compared to calcium carbonate, although the incidence of hypercalcemia is similar during treatment periods.
- Tolerance: Both drugs are generally well-tolerated, but patients more frequently complain of muscle cramps while taking calcium acetate. There is a higher incidence of intolerance with calcium acetate treatment, but the side effects are mild and easy to treat.
- Phosphate Binding Power: In vitro and in vivo studies have shown that calcium acetate is more effective at binding phosphate than calcium carbonate, allowing for better control of serum phosphorus levels with a lower dose.
- Calcium Absorption: Less calcium seems to be absorbed when calcium acetate is used, which could potentially reduce the incidence of hypercalcemia.
In conclusion, while both calcium acetate and calcium carbonate are effective phosphate-binding agents, calcium acetate has some advantages in terms of reduced hypercalcemia and increased phosphate-binding efficiency. However, it also has a higher incidence of intolerance, particularly muscle cramps.
Comparative Table: Calcium Acetate vs Calcium Carbonate
Here is a table comparing the differences between calcium acetate and calcium carbonate:
Property | Calcium Acetate | Calcium Carbonate |
---|---|---|
Chemical Formula | Ca(C2H3O2)2 | CaCO3 |
Ionic or Molecular | Ionic | Ionic |
Elemental Calcium | Contains less elemental calcium than calcium carbonate | Contains a high amount of elemental calcium |
Phosphorus Binding | Binds phosphorus more effectively than calcium carbonate in adults | Less effective than calcium acetate in binding phosphorus |
Hypercalcemia | Reduces the frequency of hypercalcemic events compared to calcium carbonate | Induces hypercalcemia, particularly if calcitriol is given simultaneously |
Oral Load of Elementary Calcium | Significantly less than calcium carbonate | Higher than calcium acetate |
Sources | Not mentioned | Eggshells, limestone, marble, and other carbonate rocks |
Production | Soaking calcium carbonate or hydrated lime in vinegar or acetic acid | Not mentioned |
Both calcium acetate and calcium carbonate are used as phosphate-binding agents, but calcium acetate has been shown to be more effective in binding phosphorus and reducing the frequency of hypercalcemic events compared to calcium carbonate. However, calcium acetate has a higher incidence of intolerance compared to calcium carbonate.
- Calcium vs Calcium Carbonate
- Calcium Carbonate vs Calcium Citrate
- Calcium Lactate vs Calcium Carbonate
- Calcium Carbonate vs Calcium Bicarbonate
- Calcium Carbonate vs Calcium Oxide
- Calcium Citrate Malate vs Calcium Carbonate
- Calcium vs Calcium Citrate
- Calcium Oxide vs Calcium Hydroxide
- Calcium Gluconate vs Calcium Chloride
- Acetic Acid vs Acetate
- Calcium Chloride vs Calcium Chloride Dihydrate
- Calcite vs Dolomite
- Calcite vs Aragonite
- Calcium vs Magnesium
- Citracal vs Caltrate
- Calcium Chloride vs Sodium Chloride
- Calcium Oxalate Monohydrate vs Calcium Oxalate Dihydrate
- Carbonate vs Bicarbonate
- Potassium Acetate vs Potassium Chloride